Leveraging behavioural food policies - for the planet, the people, and peace

Guest post by Lucia Reisch, El-Erian Professor of Behavioural Economics and Policy, Cambridge

Share

Leveraging behavioural food policies - for the planet, the people, and peace

Guest post by Professor Lucia Reisch, El Erian Institute of Behavioural Economics and Policy, University of Cambridge Judge Business School

The IPCC report published in April 2022 has an important message for demand-side policies: behaviour matters! For the first time in an IPCC Report, scientists rightly point out that to limit greenhouse gas emissions and minimise environmental and social detriment, we need all tools of the policy toolbox, including demand-side policies. Carbon cutting must include private households’ and institutions’ use of energy, transport (air travel), housing (heating), and food (beef consumption). The models predict that scaled behavioural changes can wring out a substantial amount (40 to 70%) of demand-side emissions.

Consumer behaviour matters to save the planet (climate), the people (health), and peace (food security), as highlighted in the recent IPCC reports’ demand-side policy chapter. The El Erian Institute is conducting experimental research on the effectiveness of behavioural policies to nudge food choices accordingly and reduce dependence on grain and fertilisers.

In the past five years, together with my former lab at Copenhagen Business School, I studied one type of policy in-depth: Behavioural insights-based policies aiming to steer food consumption into more sustainable food patterns. While not everyone agrees on what exactly “sustainable food choices” are - since this differs across the globe and develops over time - there is considerable agreement that for most societies, eating less ruminant meat (and more fruit and vegetables), and avoiding food waste are key strategies. The latter is also a formal UN Sustainable Development Goal (SDG 12). Such diets are not only more environmentally friendly - but also healthier, which makes them an attractive default option for climate and health-conscious caterers. Hence, the EAT-Lancet Commission has suggested a primarily plant-based “planetary healthy diet” as a target that could help feed the world within planetary boundaries. Thus, it makes a lot of sense to study healthy and sustainable diets together.

The focus on consumers in Europe is appropriate since wealthy consumers emit substantially more than others. Overall consumption fields, the top 1% of emitters, are responsible for 70 times more pollution than people in the bottom 50%. For instance, we changed the presentation of products in a Danish supermarket in a field study. Using several educational (social norm messages) and architectural nudges (salience and simplification), demand for fruit and vegetables increased. In another field study in Germany, consumers used a mobile app to track and report their everyday food decisions. Even people who identify themselves as health-conscious select food based on short-term goals, such as ease, taste, and accessibility. This strengthens existing evidence that food environments have considerable leverage to shape people’s choices. Finally, in a connected lab study, we used food labels signalling a comparatively healthy choice as “primes” to activate people’s health goals. While health goal primes alone could not increase healthy food choices, they seem to prevent unhealthier habits and can work as an immunisation booster in consumer communication.

Admittedly, the effects of these studies seem small, and the scope and scale, particular of our field studies, are limited. However, we have found (in line with many others) that behavioural approaches or “nudges”, employed by trusted actors within the food system (supermarkets, canteens), can help nudge consumer choice towards a healthy planetary pattern - if well adapted to the choice context, the target group, and the type of food choice. One of our canteen experiments has shown transparency about the nudges and avoiding reactance matter. Intermediaries such as supermarkets, public canteens, and employers have enormous leverage - and in light of the triple crisis of the present, also a responsibility.

Against the backcloth of the increasing food safety issue inflicted by the war in the “breadbasket of Europe”, Ukrainians generally adopt a healthy planetary diet that wastes fewer calories by feeding grain to animals to produce large amounts of meat, decreasing the dependence of food supplies on grain and fertilisers from that region. Moreover, plant-based proteins such as beans and pulses are far more energy-efficient than livestock. This is another compelling reason to reduce meat consumption, limiting food waste for consumers and creating motivation for intermediaries to provide food environments that support such moves.

Image Credit: Elaine Casap on Unsplash

  • 19 August 2022

    Offshore floating complexes

    We've been working with the Defence Science and Technology Laboratory (Dstl) to host a series of workshops on ‘offshore floating complexes’ (OFCs) - theoretical floating settlements with the potential to be very large in scale. Could 'floating cities' ever become a reality?
  • 19 August 2022

    Working with academia

    CSaP partnered with the Defence Science and Technology Laboratory’s (Dstl) Defence Science and Technology Futures (DSTF) programme for a project on the current state of their academic engagement, and how it could be improved.
  • 19 July 2022

    Horn Fellowship: AI, supply networks and geopolitics

    Members of CSaP's Horn Fellowship gathered together at Sidney Sussex College for a day of talks with University of Cambridge academics on AI, supply chain networks and current geopolitical issues, such as the reclassification of the “Great Powers” in Europe.
  • 22 June 2022

    Bioelectronic medicine: developing neurotechnology and wearable electronics to improve human health

    Researchers from the University of Cambridge's Bioelectronics Laboratory guided CSaP's Policy Leaders Fellows on a tour of their cutting-edge facilities, demonstrating how recent advances at the interface of electrical engineering and clinical neuroscience have the potential to transform treatment approaches across healthcare.
  • 30 May 2022

    Improving the use of evidence and evaluation in policy making

    The Centre for Science and Policy (CSaP) hosted a seminar for academics and policy professionals, led by Dame Professor Theresa Marteau and Dr Matthew Gill, exploring how to improve the use of evidence and evaluation in policy making.
  • 10 May 2022

    A nuanced look at public opinions on diversity

    The Centre for Science and Policy resumed its series of in-person seminars in collaboration with the British Academy with a discussion of The Woolf Institute’s report: “How We Get Along: The Diversity Study of England and Wales 2020”. The Institute’s Director of Research Dr Julian Hargreaves presented the findings as well as Professor Tariq Modood, Professor of Sociology, Politics and Public Policy, University of Bristol.
  • 30 March 2022

    How can biology help enhance sustainable textile design?

    London-based professor, Dr Veronika Kapsali, delivered CSaP’s final Future Leaders Fellows seminar to discuss how biology can help design materials for resource efficiency, longevity, and recovery (RELR). Dr Kapsali presented her work on an AHRC-funded initiative she leads - Bio-Inspired Textiles (BIT) - that aims to identify the potential for nature-inspired design in textile development.
  • 29 March 2022

    Democracy and distrust after the pandemic

    The University of Cambridge's 2022 Dr Seng Tee Lee Lecture was delivered by Sheila Jasanoff, Pforzheimer Professor of Science and Technology Studies at Harvard Kennedy School in the U.S. Her talk at St John's College, Cambridge, concerned how the COVID-19 pandemic has revealed the nature of our current model of trust, the political nature of expert institutions, and state-level differences in public reasoning.
  • 23 March 2022

    Archaeology and public benefit

    UKRI Future Leaders Fellow Dr. Sadie Watson led a CSaP seminar on the relationship between development-led archaeology and public benefit. Her research at the Museum of London Archaeology (MOLA) aims to establish project design strategies that will maximise the social value of future development-led archaeology projects.
  • 22 March 2022

    Prevention and early intervention to improve outcomes for children and families

    A Psychology and Education Professor from the University of Cambridge outlined the importance of addressing and treating mental health problems early on, to help improve childhood outcomes and opportunities later in life. Gordon Harold delivered a seminar for CSaP’s Policy Leaders Fellows at Newnham College, Cambridge in March 2022.
  • 16 February 2022

    The sciences of ageing and improving dementia care

    Dr Martina Zimmermann, Lecturer in Health Humanities and Health Sciences at King’s College London, discussed her work on the cultural perceptions of ageing and her project - The Sciences of Ageing and the Culture of Youth (SAACY) –as part of CSaP’s Future Leaders Fellows seminar series.
  • 15 February 2022

    Forced marriage as modern slavery

    As part of the Centre for Science and Policy’s (CSaP) Future Leaders Fellows seminar series, Dr Helen McCabe, Associate Professor in Political Theory, University of Nottingham, discussed her research on forced marriage as modern slavery.
  • 11 February 2022

    UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDG) Trade-offs

    Dr Isabel Jones, Research Fellow in Biological and Environmental Sciences at the University of Stirling delivered the third edition of CSaP’s Future Leaders Fellows Seminar series. Her research focuses on how we can achieve UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) equitably, in scenarios where one SDG may be prioritised at the expense of another.
  • 27 January 2022

    Toxic metal exposure during pregnancy

    Dr Caroline Taylor, Senior Research Fellow at Bristol Medical School, University of Bristol, delivered CSaP’s first Future Leaders Seminar of 2022. As a nutritionist and dietitian, she presented her work on the lifestyle and environmental factors that cause exposure to toxic metals in pregnancy and childhood. Dr Taylor’s project aims to evaluate NHS guidance on foods to limit or avoid during pregnancy and to provide an evidence-base for the guidance.
  • 21 December 2021

    Is institutional memory in decline?

    The Centre for Science and Policy organised a seminar hosted by Professor Dennis Grube, Co-Director of the Bennett Institute for Public Policy and Professor of Politics and Public Policy at POLIS. His talk concerned the characterisation, and supposed decline, of ‘institutional memory’.
  • 21 December 2021

    The challenges facing the environment and society

    Dr Molly Anderson led the final session of CSaP’s seminar series on government’s use of data, science, and evidence. Using her perspective of working in the Environment Agency’s Chief Scientist’s Group, she discussed the concept of reflexivity and the crucial role it could play in tackling current environmental challenges.
  • 17 December 2021

    Arm’s length bodies in the COVID-19 response

    The Centre for Science and Policy hosted a seminar on how ALBs were used in the COVID-19 response, as part of its Policy Fellow series on the government’s use of data, science, and evidence. Speakers Matthew Gill and Grant Dalton, from the Institute for Government, outlined their research on the interface between health focused ALBs and central government during the pandemic.
  • 22 May 2019

    Reflections on the Energy-PIECES secondment programme

    Secondees from the 2019 Energy-PIECES (Energy Policy Insights from Early Career Events and Secondments) project came together in May to discuss their research findings and recent experiences.
  • 11 May 2019

    So you want to work in policy?

    Many PhD students and postdocs are uncertain about what career path they want to take. A workshop organised by CSaP for the Earth System Science DTP and EnvEast DTP provided insights to help researchers consider their options.
  • 9 May 2019

    Professional development for early-career scientists

    CSaP held two professional development workshops for PhD students and postdocs to expose early-career researchers to the role science plays in government decision-making and how academics can interact with policy makers.
  • 15 April 2019

    Preparing for an ageing population: Emerging technologies in social care

    CSaP brought together care sector experts, senior policy makers, practitioners, and researchers to discuss what the care sector, NHS and government should do to speed up the development, evaluation and uptake of effective technologies for social care.
  • 8 March 2019

    It’s important not to be a climate change zealot

    In the penultimate seminar of the Christ’s Climate Seminar Series, Rebecca Willis, Independent Environmental Researcher, discusses the findings of a collaborative research project to investigate how politicians think and act on climate change.
  • 7 February 2019

    CSaP hosts Policy Fellows from the MENA region

    CSaP organised a programme of meetings for seven Policy Fellows from the MENA region (from Jordan, Lebanon, Palestine and Turkey) who visited the UK in October and November 2018.
  • 8 January 2019

    Food Security and Sustainable Rural Livelihoods in India

    A CSaP policy workshop brought together TIGR2ESS researchers, relevant academics, and Principal Scientific Adviser to the Indian Government Professor Krishnaswamy VijayRaghavan to discuss food security and sustainable rural livelihoods in India.
  • 27 July 2018

    CSaP Visiting Research Fellow receives ERC grant

    CSaP Visiting Research Fellow, Dr Alice Vadrot, has received a European Research Council grant for her work on the politics of marine biodiversity data.
  • 27 November 2017

    Peer review and grant funding: from evidence to practice

    Dr Steven Wooding, CSaP Lead for Research and Analysis, has recently completed a summary of the evidence on the effectiveness of, and burden imposed by, the grant peer review system.
  • 20 March 2017

    How to measure what can't easily be measured

    A CSaP Policy Workshop to brainstorm ideas on how the NIHR can measure the impact of its interventions brought together academic experts with senior policy makers for an exploratory discussion.
  • 13 March 2017

    What are the challenges for the future of healthcare in the UK?

    The 2017 CSaP Annual Lecture was delivered by Professor Christopher Whitty, Chief Scientific Adviser to the Department of Health, who made his predictions about the future of health in the UK.
  • 9 February 2017

    How can observations from space help tackle climate change?

    Our 2017 climate seminar series continued with a talk by Professor Stephen Briggs, a Senior Adviser in the European Space Agency, who discussed the role that space agencies are making in monitoring climate change from space, and the potential applications of their work for future mitigation.
  • 5 December 2016

    The future of cycling in the cities of tomorrow

    The replacement of driving with active forms of travel has the capacity to provide myriad health and economic benefits, says Dr David Ogilvie of the Centre for Diet and Activity Research at a recent CSaP event.
  • 1 December 2016

    Testing times for evidence and expertise: what lies ahead for science and innovation?

    Will political events of 2016 provoke a fundamental rethink of the role of institutions at the intersection of science, innovation, expertise, politics and power?
  • 19 October 2016

    Early career researchers discuss the benefits of building connections between science and policy

    CSaP organised a talk for early career researchers to gain a better understanding of the role of research in the policy development process.
  • 13 October 2016

    Why do farmers and advisers in the UK use decision support tools?

    Dr David Rose, a CSaP Visiting Research Fellow, describes recent work investigating use of tools which provide evidence-based decision-making advice to policy makers and practitioners in a useable form.
  • 18 April 2016

    What is the relationship between knowledge and practice?

    For the past two years, Clare Moran, CSaP’s Policy Fellowships Coordinator, has been co-editing a Routledge volume that explores relationships between knowledge and practice.
  • 12 April 2016

    What makes a successful research culture?

    A CSaP Policy Workshop organised in collaboration with the Higher Education Funding Council for England (HEFCE) explored research cultures, how they are formed and what influences them.
  • 23 March 2016

    Knowledge, Expertise and the Policy Process

    A report of the discussion on Professor Susan Owens' book "Knowledge, Policy and Expertise: The UK Royal Commission on Environmental Pollution 1970-2011"
  • 10 March 2016

    What will the new research funding landscape look like?

    The Centre for Science and Policy launched its 2015 annual report at a panel discussion and reception in Cambridge on 10 February.
  • 19 February 2015

    How does academic research contribute to the work of government?

    More than 140 academics and policy makers joined us at the University of Cambridge Old Schools last night for a reception to mark the launch of our latest annual report, and to hear guest speakers discuss how academic research informs the work of government.
  • 13 December 2013

    New Strategic Research Initiatives at Cambridge

    CSaP will be playing a central role in all four of the Strategic Research Initiatives by fostering connections and two-way learning between government and academia.
  • 11 April 2011

    Science and Policy Research Questions Workshop

    This one-day workshop brought together 40 prominent researchers and policy professionals to deliberate on the most important questions on the relationship between science and policy.
  • 1 October 2010

    Science and Policy Key Research Questions Programme

    We are delighted to announce the launch of an ambitious and exciting new programme in science and policy research.