Why care about decision-making?

Guest post by Fraser Battye, Principal Consultant, The Strategy Unit (NHS)


Why care about decision-making?

Guest post by Fraser Battye, Principal Consultant, The Strategy Unit (NHS)

I am obsessed with strategic decision-making. Completely obsessed. In many ways and for many reasons:

Reason 1: Improving decision making would improve many other things

There is no shortage of human ill to address, and there are no signs of a supply shock. Anyone interested in making the world a better place could exhaust multiple lifetimes of effort on the current set of problems; yet they still would not scratch the surface.

So, given the likely constraints of one lifetime and one career, where should we start?

The 80,000 Hours movement sets out to address that question. It assumes a professional life of about that length and, following a structured process, suggests ways of investing these hours to achieve maximum social good.

The 80,000 Hours list of issues to focus on is instructive. It contains items such as reducing global catastrophic biological risks, mitigating great power conflict, positively shaping the development of artificial intelligence and space governance. Quite an intimidating agenda. And then - just below nuclear security - comes ‘improving institutional decision-making’.

Their rationale for including this is interesting:

“Improving decision-making could help us to solve almost all other problems.”

This resonates strongly with my reasons for caring about decision-making.

Fraser Battye, Principal Consultant, The Strategy Unit (NHS)

I work for the Strategy Unit - an NHS team whose sole purpose is to help health and care services (and increasingly policy) understand problems, generate solutions, and measure impact. We focus on durable, strategic, complex problems. We do so aminated by a desire to maximise public value.
The Strategy Unit’s basic theory is: ‘better evidence, better decisions, better outcomes’. So, I see decision-making as foundational to helping this theory work in practice. By helping organisations improve their decision-making, my bet is that they will be more able to improve outcomes across all areas – from maternity services to end-of-life care.

Reason 2: Decision-making is undervalued

The NHS is blessed with a great deal of support when it comes to improving services. There are large-scale programmes, established methods, institutions and networks, qualifications and many more new and flourishing initiatives dedicated to improving what is currently done.

This is great, and most likely we need more of it. But there is a big gap: where is the equivalent support for deciding what to do?

The same gap can be illuminated from a different angle by asking about leadership.

The question: “What do leaders do?” elicits varied responses; nonetheless “make decisions” would appear on most people’s list. But then asking: “What training do leaders get in decision-making?” or “How should leaders understand and improve the quality of their decision making?” elicits very little but discomfort. We say decision-making is important, but we do little to improve it.

If you are a leader, how do you improve your practice as a decision-maker? How do you understand your strengths and weaknesses, your biases, and defaults? What steps are you taking to create the environment and culture to help your organisation improve the quality of its decisions? What methods and approaches do you use? And what is your agenda for improvement?

Very few can answer these questions. Even in a ~£135 billion public service like the NHS. Decision-making is an under-recognised and undervalued route to improvement.

Reason 3: Decision-making is perfect territory for generalists

Nearly every academic discipline has something to contribute to the topic of decision-making. Economics seems to rule the roost; but it has taken quite a pecking from psychology, which also finds itself scratching and jostling around with ethics, political philosophy, anthropology, epistemology, neuroscience, engineering…

This is a busy, invigorating, and sometimes bewildering, intellectual environment. It is also one that has thrown up interesting, digestible, and accessible material. Books that busy decision- makers can pick up, work through, and gather insights to adopt in practice. This includes the well-known work of people like Daniel Kahneman, Gary Klein, Cass Sunstein, Philip Tetlock, and Julia Galef. It also includes some excellent and highly applied work by psychologist-turned-poker-champion Annie Duke and consultant-turned-academic Olivier Sibony. The job of synthesis and application is well underway.

For me this creates a near-perfect set of conditions: important and complex problems; multiple perspectives, insights and debates; and a pressing set of practical tasks. It opens up stimulating territory between intellectual interest and ‘real world’ concern: how to take the best of multiple academic insights and apply them in the messy, ambiguous, and highly constrained environment of NHS decision-making?
This question has formed the basis of my Policy Fellowship at CSaP. While only part-way through, I can already see how this opportunity will add real value. When else would I find myself picking the considerable brains of experts in data science, philosophy, emergency medicine, engineering, and politics?

The need to take multiple perspectives is one of the stand-out themes in the decision-making literature; my Policy Fellowship allows me to do exactly this. And my role as a Senior Research Associate at Jesus College’s Intellectual Forum in Cambridge will allow me to further this multi-disciplinary exploration.

Reason 4: Teaching is learning

The Strategy Unit is supporting an exciting initiative in the Midlands. The Midlands Decision Support Network (MDSN) brings together the developing intelligence functions of the 11 Integrated Care Systems (ICS) in the region. It networks and supports analysts, evidence specialists, and evaluators within each ICS - equipping them to play a deeper role in local strategic decision-making.

As well as supporting those that produce insights, the MDSN works with users of the results. And, as part of that, we have developed specific education programmes, targeting leaders, on improving the quality of decisions. (We also have supplemented this with additional workshops on ‘Thinking Tools’ and ‘Economics for Non-Economists’).

Early runs of our strategic decision-making programme have received incredible feedback. Leaders – and especially clinical leaders – have really valued the opportunity to explore the topic. They have reflected on - and planned for improvements in - themselves as an individual, their teams, and organisations. We have equipped them with insights from the literature, alongside practical ‘thinking tools’, and methods. We have already begun to see changes in practice, as participants use these materials in their day-to-day work.

I have loved it. Studying helps learning, but I find working with others to be a faster and richer route. I have learnt a lot from participants on the MDSN programme. Working closely with local decision-makers, helping them to address their challenges and to plan for practical improvement: it is here that the value of programmes like the CSaP Policy Fellowship become most obvious.

Spreading the word matters too. So I have tried to capture, develop and share emerging insights. Partly by constantly iterating and improving our training material, and partly in a series of (currently eight) short blogs on strategic decision-making – covering topics such as intuition, the need to seek and structure disagreement, and the power of questioning.

This will remain work in progress. My aim is to keep exploring the evidence; to gain stimulation and ideas from Cambridge and the literature; and to support decision-makers through the practical tasks of applying these insights.

All things equal, and with a fair wind, I'm about half-way through my 80,000 hours. I have an enthusiastic sense of how I want to spend the next several thousand.

Image Credit: Mitchell Luo on Unsplash

  • 5 September 2023

    Learning lessons from the Covid-19 pandemic

    Richard Gleave, UK Health Security Agency, and Professor Sharon Peacock, Department of Medicine, University of Cambridge, discussed the wider implications of the COVID-19 pandemic, reflecting on the success of the UK’s COVID-19 Genomics Consortium (COG-UK) in pandemic response and, more broadly, on the evolving role of scientific advice in times of public crises.
  • 4 July 2023

    Reading group on Five Times Faster #1: Rethinking the science of climate change

    In June, the Cambridge Zero Policy Forum met for the first of four reading group sessions, on Five Times Faster: Rethinking the Science, Economics, and Diplomacy of Climate Change, by Senior Fellow at the World Resources Institute, Simon Sharpe.
  • 9 June 2023

    Mobilising green investment: challenges and opportunities for the UK economy

    This Cambridge Zero Policy forum seminar explored the second Green Finance Strategy published on 30 March 2023, with Ben Fagan-Watson, Head of the Green Finance Team, Net Zero Strategy Directorate.
  • 3 May 2023

    Understanding the role of place in environmental sustainability

    This seminar explored key messages from a series of British Academy-funded projects on sustainability and discussed the implications with contributions from CSaP Policy Fellows.
  • 21 October 2022

    The digitisation of health and social care

    The Capabilities in Academic Policy Engagement (CAPE) team at the University of Cambridge’s Centre for Science and Policy (CSaP) hosted a day of talks for members of the Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) to discuss the digital transformation of healthcare services.
  • 19 August 2022

    Offshore floating complexes

    We've been working with the Defence Science and Technology Laboratory (Dstl) to host a series of workshops on ‘offshore floating complexes’ (OFCs) - theoretical floating settlements with the potential to be very large in scale. Could 'floating cities' ever become a reality?
  • 19 August 2022

    Equitable collaborations

    This year, CSaP partnered with the Wellcome Sanger Institute for a series of workshops on equity in international research collaborations––a fair distribution of responsibilities, benefits, and kudos between low and middle-income country (LMIC) researchers and high-income country (HIC) researchers.
  • 30 June 2022

    A ‘greenprint’ for net zero in UK transport by 2050

    A cross-disciplinary group of academics met with Richard Bruce, DfT Director of Transport Decarbonisation, and Dr Bob Moran, DfT Deputy Director of Decarbonisation Strategy, for a Cambridge Zero Policy Forum discussion, bringing a broad range of academic expertise from across the University of Cambridge to bear on the challenges and opportunities raised by the DfT’s transport decarbonisation plans.
  • 22 June 2022

    Bioelectronic medicine: developing neurotechnology and wearable electronics to improve human health

    Researchers from the University of Cambridge's Bioelectronics Laboratory guided CSaP's Policy Leaders Fellows on a tour of their cutting-edge facilities, demonstrating how recent advances at the interface of electrical engineering and clinical neuroscience have the potential to transform treatment approaches across healthcare.
  • 31 May 2022

    Universities as anchor institutions

    The Centre for Science and Policy continued its series of in-person seminars on social infrastructure topics in collaboration with the British Academy on 26 May 2022, with a discussion on universities as anchor institutions.
  • 17 May 2022

    What do we mean by a Science Superpower?

    George Freeman MP, Minister for Science, Research, and Innovation delivered a CSaP Lecture at St John’s College, Cambridge where he discussed the UK’s position within global research and innovation. The talk on 28 April 2022 explored the mission of making Britain a “Science Superpower”.
  • 10 May 2022

    A nuanced look at public opinions on diversity

    The Centre for Science and Policy resumed its series of in-person seminars in collaboration with the British Academy with a discussion of The Woolf Institute’s report: “How We Get Along: The Diversity Study of England and Wales 2020”. The Institute’s Director of Research Dr Julian Hargreaves presented the findings as well as Professor Tariq Modood, Professor of Sociology, Politics and Public Policy, University of Bristol.
  • 6 April 2022

    Science advice and government: Ebola

    For CSaP's Science and Policy Podcast, the Centre's Executive Director Dr Rob Doubleday was joined by Sir Oliver Letwin, a former Cabinet Minister, Professor Melissa Leach, Director of the Institute of Development Studies at the University of Sussex, and Professor Dame Sally Davies, former Chief Medical Officer for England, to discuss how science advice was used by decision-makers during the Ebola Outbreak in 2014.
  • 23 March 2022

    Archaeology and public benefit

    UKRI Future Leaders Fellow Dr. Sadie Watson led a CSaP seminar on the relationship between development-led archaeology and public benefit. Her research at the Museum of London Archaeology (MOLA) aims to establish project design strategies that will maximise the social value of future development-led archaeology projects.
  • 4 March 2022

    Global Pandemic Response, Public Health and Sustainability

    The University of Cambridge Vice-Chancellor's Lecture was held on 01 March 2022 and was delivered online by Dr Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, Director-General, World Health Organization. The lecture series, which engages partners from CEENRG and CSAP as well as CISDL and others, is driven by the urgency to inspire and innovate the world’s best and brightest minds.
  • 16 February 2022

    The sciences of ageing and improving dementia care

    Dr Martina Zimmermann, Lecturer in Health Humanities and Health Sciences at King’s College London, discussed her work on the cultural perceptions of ageing and her project - The Sciences of Ageing and the Culture of Youth (SAACY) –as part of CSaP’s Future Leaders Fellows seminar series.
  • 15 February 2022

    Sustainable finance, risk and transition to clean technology

    CSaP in collaboration with Professor Charles Kennel, Director Emeritus at the Scripps Institution of Oceanography, University of California San Diego, delivered the 2022 series of climate change seminars hosted by Christ’s College, Cambridge. The first focused on sustainable finance, risk, and the transition to clean technology. It was chaired by Emily Farnworth, Co-Director, Hughes Hall Centre for Climate Engagement, with two panellists: Michael Liebreich, Chairman and CEO, Liebreich Associates, and Emily Shuckburgh, Director of Cambridge Zero at University of Cambridge.
  • 11 February 2022

    UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDG) Trade-offs

    Dr Isabel Jones, Research Fellow in Biological and Environmental Sciences at the University of Stirling delivered the third edition of CSaP’s Future Leaders Fellows Seminar series. Her research focuses on how we can achieve UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) equitably, in scenarios where one SDG may be prioritised at the expense of another.
  • 20 January 2022

    Life in the Anthropocene

    CSaP’s Horn Fellows hosted an evening event for academics and policy makers, in conjunction with Cambridge Zero. Howard Covington, Chair of the Alan Turing Institute, discussed the history of the Anthropocene, an unofficial term for the geological period we are currently living in, and his projections for the future.
  • 21 December 2021

    The challenges facing the environment and society

    Dr Molly Anderson led the final session of CSaP’s seminar series on government’s use of data, science, and evidence. Using her perspective of working in the Environment Agency’s Chief Scientist’s Group, she discussed the concept of reflexivity and the crucial role it could play in tackling current environmental challenges.
  • 17 December 2021

    The science of mitigating natural disasters

    As part of CSaP’s seminar series on government data, science, and evidence, Dr Amy Donovan from the University of Cambridge led a discussion on how science is used to generate effective warning systems in the face of impending natural disasters or environmental risks.
  • 17 December 2021

    Arm’s length bodies in the COVID-19 response

    The Centre for Science and Policy hosted a seminar on how ALBs were used in the COVID-19 response, as part of its Policy Fellow series on the government’s use of data, science, and evidence. Speakers Matthew Gill and Grant Dalton, from the Institute for Government, outlined their research on the interface between health focused ALBs and central government during the pandemic.
  • 7 December 2021

    How can data science inform infrastructure policy?

    As part of the CSaP Policy Fellow seminar series on government’s use of data, science and evidence, Mark Enzer, Chief Technical Officer for Mott MacDonald and Director of the Centre for Digital Built Britain, led a discussion on how data science can be used to inform infrastructure policy.
  • 19 November 2021

    Moving forward with social infrastructure policy

    The Centre for Science and Policy (CSaP) held a workshop on social infrastructure at the British Academy. It was organised in partnership with the British Academy, the Bennett Institute of Public Policy, and Power to Change. The attendees were academics, advocates, policymakers, and researchers with expertise in social infrastructure policy.
  • 14 October 2021

    Climate change and the economy: what COP26 needs to know

    With weeks to go until COP26, CSaP's Executive Director Rob Doubleday talks to two of Cambridge's leading economists Dr Matthew Agarwala and Dr Cristina Peñasco, about what leaders need to know and do, to delivery a clean, green recovery. The event was hosted as part of the University of Cambridge's Alumni Festival 2021.
  • 13 October 2021

    The rapid decarbonisation of healthcare

    Healthcare is one of the largest contributors to the UK’s total carbon footprint. Throughout the COVID-19 pandemic the NHS experienced a rapid change in the delivery of healthcare: can this sense of critical urgency be harnessed and applied to the decarbonisation of the National Health Service?
  • 15 December 2020

    Science, Policy & A Green Recovery: Planetary Health and Human Health

    Could climate change or deforestation cause the next pandemic? In the final episode of our series on Science, Policy and a Green Recovery, host Dr Rob Doubleday and guest host Kate McNeil explore the links between planetary health and human health. Throughout the episode, they hear about how human activity is placing pressure on the natural world and how that can influence the risks posed by zoonotic and vector-borne diseases. They also address how unsustainable human activities and climate change are contributing threats to human health from non-communicable diseases and as a consequence of natural disasters.
  • 1 May 2020

    Soil Health in the United Kingdom

    What would an agricultural soil plan for the UK look like and which measures would we use to monitor its effectiveness? Do we know enough about soil and soil health indicators to be able to operationalize policies that would ensure that soil health is looked after and which would ensure that land gives us the kind of benefits that we collectively decide we want?
  • 24 October 2019

    What drives social cohesion and what interventions can be used to improve it?

    Professor Sarah Curtis discussed place and social cohesion at the first in a series of workshops on cohesive societies hosted by CSaP and the British Academy.
  • 7 November 2018

    How can we make the best use of urban green space?

    CSaP's Policy Workshop, held in collaboration with the London Borough of Barking and Dagenham and Grow Wild, brought together practitioners, residents, academics and local government officials together at Eastbury Manor House to discuss the best uses of small pockets of urban green space.
  • 9 July 2018

    Behaviour change, nudging and the nanny state

    The first session at CSaP's annual conference was chaired by Dr Helen Munn, Director of the Academy of Medical Sciences, and included world leading experts on behaviour change from the University of Cambridge, UCL and Defra.
  • 7 April 2017

    The impact of ride sharing apps on urban mobility

    Planning for the future of urban mobility balances the need to reduce the amount of cars on the road whilst also maximising access to transportation. A meeting for CSaP's Policy Fellows considered 'The Future of Urban Mobility'.
  • 29 March 2017

    What will future transport systems look like in the UK?

    As part of the Government Foresight Project into the Future of Mobility, CSaP organised a Policy Workshop which brought together representatives from the Government Office for Science with experts from academia and industry to discuss potential social and demographic issues which are likely to influence mobility over the next few decades.
  • 16 February 2017

    How can machine learning techniques improve our understanding of climate change risks in the future?

    Dr Emily Shuckburgh explains how machine learning techniques can be used to improve climate model predictions and provide a more sophisticated understanding of climate change risks in the future.
  • 2 February 2017

    How can we reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 2050?

    In the second of the 2017 climate seminar series, Clive Maxwell, Director General of Energy Transformation at the Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy, described some of the technologies and initiatives put in place by the UK government to reduce carbon emissions, and some of the challenges we still face in tackling climate change.
  • 26 January 2017

    How can earth's vital signs help us to monitor the impacts of climate change?

    The 2017 Climate Change Seminar Series kicked off in January with a talk on how understanding earth’s “vital signs” could aid efforts to adapt to, and mitigate, climate change.
  • 5 December 2016

    The future of cycling in the cities of tomorrow

    The replacement of driving with active forms of travel has the capacity to provide myriad health and economic benefits, says Dr David Ogilvie of the Centre for Diet and Activity Research at a recent CSaP event.
  • 7 November 2016

    How can we use evidence to reduce poverty in the UK?

    What would it take to solve UK poverty? At a recent reception celebrating the new plan from the Joseph Rowntree Foundation (JRF) to solve poverty in the UK, CSaP Policy Leaders Fellow Julia Unwin spoke about the accomplishments of JRF during her tenure as Chief Executive, and the challenges and possibilities ahead.
  • 2 November 2016

    Strategic challenges for the health system

    The strategic challenges for the economic sustainability of the NHS was the topic of conversation at a recent CSaP Policy Fellow event held in the Department of Health
  • 20 October 2016

    Multi-level governance of climate change: CSaP Policy Workshop

    The Paris Agreement has been hailed as a major step in global climate change mitigation efforts, but how can different levels of governance work together to make the promises of Paris a reality? CSaP held a Policy Workshop bringing together climate specialists to discuss this question.
  • 27 September 2016

    Honest advocacy for nature: presenting a persuasive narrative for conservation

    This paper presents the case of the Lawton Review, which was able to seize on an opportunity to communicate a rigorously argued, persuasive and practical conservation message; in other words, it performed ‘honest advocacy’.
  • 8 August 2016

    Public Health: Research into Policy

    Case study on meningitis vaccinations from Public Health: Research into Policy project.
  • 12 May 2016

    How can we build flood resilience in the UK?

    Earlier this month, a group of experts from the University of Cambridge convened a one-day seminar to discuss river and coastal flooding in the UK, and how to manage risks and improve resilience in flood-prone communities.
  • 21 March 2016

    What can Cambridge do about climate change?

    In our final seminar of the 2016 Climate Change series, we heard from a panel of experts on what Cambridge could do to drive progress in sustainable living and combatting climate change.
  • 29 February 2016

    Harnessing the potential of social movements, and generating impact at scale

    A Policy Workshop held in collaboratioin with Friends of the Earth, the Nesta Health Lab and the Cambridge Institute of Public Health, brought together a wide range of Policy Fellows from the health and environment sectors to discuss the role of social movements, innovation, and impact at scale.
  • 11 February 2016

    How can buildings be made more efficient in combatting carbon emissions?

    In the second of the 2016 seminar series, Simon Sharpe (Foreign and Commonwealth Office) and Professor Ian Leslie (Cambridge Computer Laboratory) discussed how the risks of climate change are communicated, and how buildings could be made to be more efficient in combatting carbon emissions.
  • 10 December 2015

    Linking transport, health and wellbeing

    A Professional Development Policy Workshop looking at the role of evidence and expertise in making transport policy, with a particular focus on how it can influence health and wellbeing.
  • 4 November 2015

    Is climate change about to claim its first cities?

    Extreme heatwaves could create conditions in several Middle Eastern cities that would exceed the threshold of what human beings can endure.
  • 8 September 2015

    Visions of Cambridge in 2065: report launch on 8 September 2015

    What is your vision of Cambridge in 2065? This is the question being asked by 'Visions of Cambridge in 2065', one of 6 city case studies supported by the Foresight Future of Cities project.
  • 27 March 2015

    The challenges and opportunities facing our cities

    A panel of speakers brought together the challenges and opportunities presented by rapid growth and urbanisation of cities.
  • 6 February 2015

    Connectivity and flow in future cities

    In 2014, for the first time, more people live in cities than in rural areas. By 2050, more than 70% of people are predicted to be living in cities
  • 5 February 2015

    Podcast available: Cities in a changing climate

    A podcast of our event on resilient cities is now available.
  • 17 November 2014

    CSaP Policy Workshop: Affordable Housing

    CSaP teamed up with the Cambridge Centre for Housing Planning Research (CCHPR) to run a workshop to discuss policy options for improving the supply of affordable housing.
  • 20 March 2014

    If you were planning a sustainable city, what would you include in it?

    What will the impact of increasing numbers of people living in cities be on society, or biodiversity, or on food, water and energy security?